Skip to Content

Make New Wood Look Like Old Barn Wood

Finding authentic old barn wood is more challenging than you’d think! It can be costly even if you’re lucky enough to find this treasured wood. So here’s how I made new wood look like old barn wood with distressing techniques.

New Wood can look like old barn wood with these easy step by step instructions.  Easy DIY project.
DIY Kitchen Island

I love the look of AUTHENTIC old barn wood, but it’s EXPENSIVE! Since I was determined that my kitchen island would have a barn wood top, I had to improvise to stay within our budget!

Purchase New Wood

First, determine what wood to use for your countertop. We choose new 2 x 8 pine boards because I like the look of a thicker board.

Next, you need to cut the boards into lengths to fit your cabinet top or island.

In addition, you will need to use a plate biscuit joiner, joining biscuits, and wood glue to attach the boards together.

Also, you will need to use wood clamps to hold the boards in place until the wood glue has dried.

New Wood can look like old barn wood with these easy step by step instructions.  Easy DIY project.

(Posts on The Ponds Farmhouse may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. See the full disclosure details here.)


How To Make New Wood Look Like Old Barn Wood?

Once you have the top attached, it’s time to turn these new boards into old barn wood.

First, the wood is distressed by hammering nails and screws into the surface. Using a file, you can round the edges where the boards with attached.

We had pulled some vintage handmade nails from an old door frame, and I embedded some of those nails into the wood. You want scares and nail holes in the wood because that is what you would have if it were pulled from an old barn.

You can see nail and screw marks on the side of the wood.

DIY Project to make new wood look like old barn wood for a kitchen island counter top.  See step by Step instructions.

How To Stain To Look like Old Barn Wood?

The first step is using Minwax Classic Grey Stain. Apply the oil-based stain with an absorbent cloth and protective gloves. This first step ages the wood to a fine grey finish.

Once the surface is sufficiently covered (not necessarily dry), begin layering with Minwax Gel Stains in two-three colors, mixing them into the original stain and creating light and dark areas on the wood. For this project, I used Walnut and Aged Oak Stains.

I used a cloth to apply the stains and blended until I was happy with the colors.

DIY Project to make new wood look like old barn wood for a kitchen island counter top.  See step by Step instructions.
Cup Pull Hardware was added to island drawers.

Buff the Stain

Once you are happy with the colors, use a clean cloth to buff the surface. If an area becomes too light, you can always add more stain.

At this point, you want stains to dry for approx. one week and then apply a very thin coat of Matt Polyurethane to seal the surface, using a sponge roller.

Note: I always apply a thin coat to start and the second coat of sealer in about three days. Trying to build up the sealer too quickly will result in bubbles and possible peeling of the sealer.

DIY Project to make new wood look like old barn wood for a kitchen island counter top.  See step by Step instructions.

The DIY Kitchen Island is one of our favorite DIY Projects ever and all the details are in this post! Link to Bar Stools here.


We love the results of this project and have used the technique for several other projects, such as our open shelving, stair steps, and front doors.

If you have any questions, please feel free to ask! If you are looking for more DIY projects, you may enjoy How to build a Faux Apothecary Cabinet.

See this industrial farmhouse kitchen tour.

PIN IT TO REMEMBER IT

DIY Project to make new wood look like old barn wood for a kitchen island counter top.  See step by Step instructions on how to distress wood to achieve an aged look.  #distressed #barnwood

Cheryl

Saturday 23rd of September 2023

Thank you for your beautiful inspiration 😍 and sharing your DIY information 🥰

Rachel

Saturday 23rd of September 2023

Cheryl, I'm so glad you found this helpful. Thanks for commenting.

Sondra

Sunday 16th of August 2020

Hi Rachel, Love the end result of this project! Can you tell me what was used on the edges of the countertop?

[email protected]

Sunday 16th of August 2020

Sondra, Thanks so much. Are you referring to the island top? If so, there is no edge, it's just the boards. If you're referring to the concrete countertops, they are solid concrete. I appreciate you for stopping by. Rachel

Minnie Breazlan

Sunday 9th of February 2020

Your ceiling!! - how did you do that?!?! I love it!

[email protected]

Sunday 9th of February 2020

Minnie, Thank you for your response. I began with the same technique as the barn wood island top. But instead of staining after the Gray Stain, I used a dry brush technique to apply the White Dove paint to the ceiling. White Dove by Benjamin Moore is what the shiplap walls are painted..

Kristin

Saturday 8th of February 2020

This is so wonderful!! What a great tutorial!

[email protected]

Saturday 8th of February 2020

Thanks so much Kristin! I appreciate you so much.